Where to Eat on Tilghman Island, Maryland
Tilghman Island, a serene and picturesque watermen’s village on Maryland’s Eastern Shore, offers a laid-back dining scene with plenty of coastal charm. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh seafood, classic American fare, or a casual waterfront meal, Tilghman Island has something to satisfy your cravings. Here are some of the best restaurants to check out when visiting Tilghman Island.
Start Your Day Right
Start your day at Two if by Sea, a cozy, chef-owned restaurant known for its hearty breakfast and brunch offerings, which incorporate fresh seafood. Locals and visitors alike rave about their crab benedict and other seafood specialties. Two if by Sea hosts cooking classes and special dinners throughout the year, which you can find on our calendar of events.
Dine by the Water on Tilghman Island
If you’re looking for a true Maryland crab experience, Tickler’s Crab Shack & Restaurant, at the Wylder Hotel Tilghman Island is a great option. This casual, no-frills eatery offers some of the freshest steamed crabs, crab cakes, and seafood platters around. Enjoy your meal outside on the deck with views of the working waterfront and soak in the island’s charm. Inside the hotel, Bar Mumbo offers a laid-back yet lively atmosphere with a fantastic selection of craft cocktails, small plates, and creative dishes. It’s the perfect place to unwind after a day of exploring Tilghman Island.
For a dining experience with stunning waterfront views, Blue Waterfront Restaurant at the Tilghman Island Inn is a top choice. Specializing in locally inspired cuisine, with meat, seafood, and produce options locally sourced, Blue Waterfront offers both indoor and outdoor dining options.
If you’re a fan of Gina’s in St. Michaels, check out their newest location, Gina’s at the Bridge. You’ll find an expanded menu featuring new flavors that utilize local finds and pair well with their infamous margaritas.
More than a Market
A hidden gem, the Tilghman Island Country Store is more than just a market—it’s also a great place to grab a delicious sandwich, fresh baked goods, and gourmet snacks. Their made-to-order breakfast and lunch options make it a favorite stop for locals and travelers passing through. Don’t forget to stock up on local goods and specialty foods while you’re there and stop by for their Friday@Five for a toast.
Plan Your Tilghman Island Culinary Adventure
No trip to Tilghman Island is complete without indulging in the local flavors. From classic Maryland seafood to chef-driven cuisine, the island’s restaurants offer something for every palate. Whether you’re dining with a waterfront view, picking up a quick bite, or savoring a crab feast, you’re sure to enjoy the flavors of this charming destination.
Looking for more things to do while you’re here? Check out our page on Tilghman Island for recommendations on where to stay, what to see, and how to make the most of your visit!
