Evan Glasier

3 out of 5 stars★★★☆☆

Micro portions of food for the setting and place. There were flies buzzing around the table and even though the service was good I won’t return.

Mark Breth

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

My wife Missy and I had the most extra special dinner ever ! Thank you to the Chef that was working on Saturday July 25 at the time of our reservation which I could not remember his name, Stacey, Vi cent the food and beverage director, Abbie our server and Vickie who served us 7 yrs ago and the next day saw her for breakfast at the Robert Morris Inn. We left St Michael's by boat one day and stopped in Oxford and saw her again. We never forgot her and here she was again and remembered us. What an unforgettable dinner this will be. Everyone made it extra special.

Tina Langnes

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

What a lovely, historic peaceful place! Oh the view with the boats coming in the bay! The food was fantastic! We ate outside! We had reservations for 5. The portions were good sized. You can bring your pet if you like outside seating is available! They also have rooms you can stay at ! I heard from guests how nice they were! I can’t image! It is on the pricer side! But it didn’t disappoint!

Colton Simmons

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

We loved our experience at Stars. Great wine selection, and every dish was light, creative, and delicious. The crab cakes are a must – and I’m not even a fan of crab generally speaking. Can’t go wrong with a table and a view either!

Chad Adams

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

STARS Restaurant is located at the Inn at Perry Cabin in Saint Michael’s. In my opinion, this is the absolute best restaurant in Saint Michael’s. We went there for dinner and also brunch and everything was absolutely amazing! Their service is absolutely top-notch, their food is absolutely amazing and the overall experience and setting is top-notch. We sat inside for the brunch and then we sat outside for dinner and the views overlooking the harbor, the outdoor seating with fire pits, it really is a wonderful dining experience. Would highly recommend this restaurant for breakfast, brunch and also dinner.

Dennis Quinn

3 out of 5 stars★★★☆☆

This is a solid B-minus "fine dining" restaurant serving average food for above-average prices. Now, you can argue that you're paying for the location, but let's be honest — the view isn't going to be that spectacular from your table. (Get a drink at the excellent bar and take it out to the Adirondack chairs facing the water, if that's what interests you.) The food is fine, but not particularly interesting: the same steaks, chops, fish, crab cakes with "fancy" touches that dominate the mainstream. (The appetizers sound a bit more imaginative than the entrees on the menu, but both the mushroom toast and sea bass crudo were pretty underwhelming in person.) The service is friendly but unexceptional: we had to give reminders when certain dishes or drinks didn't appear. The atmosphere definitely scores for being a step above the usual hotel restaurant, but not by much, and the live music was Applebees-level entertainment. I'd rather have no music, thanks. It's all just a little safe, boring, run of the mill. You've been there and done that, and you can get a lot more for $100+ per person — more food, more imagination, more fun. Go elsewhere.

Cherie Santos-Wuest

4 out of 5 stars★★★★☆

Been dining at Stars for over 13 years, before it was rebranded. Food is still stellar, although the menu has been simplified. It's a shame the service has not kept up with he qulaity and execution of the dishes.